joker-movie-2019
Entertainment Feature Post

Joker: Cinematic masterpiece or vanity project?

Its 8:10 pm. I have arrived home after thirty minutes earlier having watched ‘JOKER’, Joaquin Phoenix’s latest attempt at portraying the clown prince of Gotham and a blank screen awaits the first stroke of the key.

All it takes is a mask and a gun … and you’ve changed things!

Opening up my Batman themed spiral notebook to my left housing my notes, I stare through my office window for a brief second, looking for inspiration for my inaugural piece title to a pastel grey sky as a flock of swallows fly by about to bring in the torrential rain I am expecting this time of year. In front of me is my computer and I am about to write my very first review. And somehow, the ominous weather outside my window feels appropriate. I am remembered by Anne Hathaway as Catwoman in Christopher’s Nolan’s ‘The Dark Knight Rises’ “There is a storm coming Mr. Wayne”(okay, no more Batman references, we came here for the single greatest villain in comic book history, arguably in all of non-fiction, so let’s have him have his day shall we? ). In one way or another, I imagine the feline burglar was prophesizing what the producers of Joker would hope to have critics tout as the whirlwind performance that was to come to cinemas this year, and perhaps a potential Oscar nod?

Eight Minute Standing Ovation

And here I am faced with the question, is Joker a cinematic masterpiece worthy of its eight minute standing ovation in Venice at its premier? Or is it nothing more than a vanity project, an actor’s self-indulgency into an exploration of their own craft?

Perhaps it’s a bit of both.

Joker is written and directed by ‘The Hangover’ alumni Todd Phillips whose fraternity style humor may at first feel at odds to this ‘Mean Streets’ meets ‘Taxi-Driver’ inspired outing, but with a film predicated on dark and gritty subject manner, levity and a sense of understanding humor would seem to benefit a project based on a character that lacks the ability to differentiate pain from humor. After all, is laughter not a mask of pain? A question the film doesn’t ask blatantly, but rather lets you experience through every nuanced inclination in Phoenix’s angular, gaunt face as he traverses the underbelly of the impoverished urban jungle, taking regular beatings, constant ridicule by his peers and an apathetic councilor who really serves no other purpose than to prescribe medication, an obvious theme of demonizing America’s dependency on medication and possible link to depression as a side effect, a hypothesis the film feels needs to be put forward, but not answered.

Arthur Fleck

Joker Movie 2019
Joker - 2019

The first act setup is straightforward. Our protagonist, Arthur Fleck, is a modest man who works as a ‘clown for hire’, a low-paying job he undertakes as a cathartic gateway, his self-worth projected upon him through the eyes of the ones he makes laugh, and a doting son to his bed ridden mother who installs in him the value of a smile, a survival mechanism to hide an inelegant truth, as well as falling for the girl at the end of the hall (even villains are allowed to fall in love). Arthur suffers from a mental disorder known as Pseudobulbar affect (PBA), an emotional incontinence whereby he suffers random bouts of uncontrollable crying and laughter, a real life mental disorder that a quick internet deep dive reveals according to an unmentioned 2011 study, 1.8 million to 7.1 million Americans suffer from with just over 40% having been diagnosed correctly.

Manic Depression

And this is where the film feels it should rest its weight upon. The second act of the film is a heavy one. This act does not shy away from its main theme, that of manic depression. This act allows for Phoenix to delve into the bulk of his pre-misnomer Joker, exploring the psychological impacts of the catalysts, (a public vilification being one, the other a shocking revelation) that sends what little is left of his rational world crumbling down.

For the sake of objectivity, the only negative aspect of the second act, and it is a minor one, is that the mental context is somewhat hard to decipher as Phoenix is on full dedication and commitment to pushing his emotional boundaries while at the same time displaying a paradoxical facility, a tapestry upon which he has been given free rein to weave every emotional nuance and pathos to invoke our utmost sympathy, which at times would definitely bog down a film for those thinking that they are walking into an archetypal origins story. It is here where writer Todd Phillips feels the antagonist of the film is revealed. An antagonist that is both shocking and possibly upsetting to the hardcore Batman fans.

Joker movie writer -Todd Phillips
Todd Phillips

Once Arthur becomes the nomenclature he is destined to be, we have a very quick, yet unorthodox climax (which I feel is due to the second eating up the first half of the third act). This is not a final act showdown with lasers and alien invasions, but rather the pinnacle of one man’s journey in finding himself in a world that once didn’t recognize him, but now admires the newly adapted anarchist ideology he stands for.

Conclusion

So to answer my question, no, I don’t Joker will be recognized as one of the cinematic greats, and among the slew of heavyweight Marvel movies lined up for 2020, the film will sadly fall to the side in comic book adaption history as the masses flock to see forthcoming blockbuster action serials and special effects vehicles. Despite an expected powerhouse performance by Phoenix, the film fails at cementing itself as one of the cinematic greats, as it does very little in creating a complex or engaging storyline and relies purely on Phoenix to carry it through. After all, the most recognizable movies always have the best storylines.

In conclusion, Joker is a stand-alone film. It doesn’t tie into anything and neither does it attempt to set up any cinematic universe. It is not an R-Rated rebellious rite of passage film that a pubescent feels he should sneak into to see blood, guts, sex and gratuitous violence thrown at the screen. Joker is instead a mild character study, a performance driven art piece with themes of personal reinvention as well as humanizing villain reverence whilst making no qualms on portraying societal stigma towards mental health.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *